Rare 1939 Jefferson Nickel Could Fetch $350,000 At Auction

Rare coins often captivate collectors, and the 1939 Jefferson Nickel is among those with potential for high value under exceptional circumstances. While ordinary circulated examples are modestly priced, certain rare varieties in top condition could achieve much higher figures — even approaching hundreds of thousands of dollars in collector auctions.

Here’s what you need to know about what makes this 1939 nickel potentially worth $350,000, and what minimum standards must be met for such a price.

Key Features & Varieties

Certain versions and features of the 1939 Jefferson Nickel earn it boosted value:

• “Reverse of 1938” variety: Some 1939 coins carry the reverse die used for 1938, creating a mismatched look.
• Doubled Monticello: Error where the Monticello building on the reverse shows doubling.
• Full Steps: Sharp, well-defined steps on the Monticello reverse are highly prized.
• High Mint State grade: Examples in MS67, MS68, or above with full luster and minimal flaws are rare and sought after.

Current Market Values & Auction Records

Here are some recorded auction and guide values for high-grade 1939 Jefferson Nickels and their varieties:

Specimen / Variety	Auction Record / Guide Value
1939 Reverse of 1938, MS (Mint State)	Around $5,287
1939 Doubled Monticello, MS	Approx $23,500
1939 Reverse of 1940, MS	Similar range (~ $23,500)
Regular circulated 1939 Jefferson	A few dollars to low hundreds, depending on condition
Exceptional, possibly “Perfect” or ultra-high grade rare variety	Speculative — some believe $200,000-$500,000 possible

If a coin meets all the rare variety criteria, flawless grading, and comes with excellent provenance, $350,000 could be within its reach.

What Makes a Coin Worth That Much

To approach six-figure values, several criteria must align:

1. Extremely high grade: MS67, MS68, MS69 — very few specimens in this range.
2. Rare die variety / error: Exactly correct mint mark, reverse, or anomalies like doubling, etc.
3. Full steps and sharp strike: A full, crisp strike with details preserved (especially “steps” on Monticello).
4. Provenance / certification: Graded by reputable services (PCGS, NGC), clear ownership history.
5. Low population: Very few known specimens in that condition or with that error.

Why the $350,000 Number Is Speculative

• Many price guides and auction records for 1939 Jefferson Nickels show values up to $25,000-$30,000 for the better ones, not $350,000.
• To reach $350,000, a coin would need to be nearly perfect, extremely rare version, possibly with a die variety that’s unheard of or unique.
• Collector interest, auction buzz, and condition scarcity all must align — that kind of dynamic rarely occurs.

Investment Advice & Considerations

• Always get coins certified by major grading agencies. Without certification, claims of “top value” are far less credible.
• Compare auction records for similar varieties. Just because someone speculates a price does not mean the market will pay it.
• Understand condition gradations: even small scratches or wear dramatically reduce value.
• If you own one, store it properly, avoid further damage, maintain provenance documentation.

While a 1939 Jefferson Nickel selling for $350,000 is not yet documented in mainstream auction records, it’s not an impossible scenario — but only if a specimen has rare variety, superb condition, certification, and collector demand.

For most holders, the value will be far lower, though still above face value for many circulated or minor error varieties. For collectors, though, this coin remains a fascinating opportunity — one with potential for extraordinary value if all stars align.

FAQs